Yes, the so-called Dignity Act is just another tired amnesty for illegals
A good look at this bill indicates Republicans gain nothing and Democrats wallow in the goodies.
Monica Showalter | April 8, 2026 www.americanthinker.com
https://www.americanthinker.com/blog/2026/04/yes_the_so_called_dignity_act_is_just_another_tired_amnesty_for_illegals.html
Amid President Trump's successful border-surge shutdown, there's always someone looking to bring up amnesty for illegal immigrants, claiming humane motives, but in fact perpetuating the Democrat political project of replacing the electorate with Chavista-style foreigners who will always vote Democrat.
H.R. 3293, introduced last year, is known as the Dignity Act, or the “Dignity for Immigrants while Guarding our Nation to Ignite and Deliver the American Dream Act of 2025” (DIGNIDAD Act, to use the Spanish word for 'dignity,') is going around again, purporting to iron out some of the bugs in U.S. immigration policy, and is intended to create a kinder, gentler illegal immigration system, while supposedly toughening border security.
Sponsored by Miami's Rep. Maria Elvira Salazar, a Cuban-American Republican, and Rep. Veronica Escobar, a Texas border-region Democrat, it supposedly has growing bipartisan support, with about 35 lawmakers onboard from both parties signing on, which is yes, higher than its original 20. And it's certainly getting a lot of press now.
It claims to be tough on illegal immigration and 'not amnesty.'
Salazar tweets:
1/
Brandon, let’s get something straight: I want DIGNITY for Americans and I put
Americans first.
Here are the facts: https://t.co/LuYMeHjdkk
— Rep. MarĂa Elvira Salazar (@RepMariaSalazar) April 8, 2026
She's been making the video rounds, too:
Rep.
Salazar tried to explain how the Dignity Act isn’t mass amnesty and is
beneficial to the American people.
It went as poorly as you would expect. Send this legislation to the trash where
it belongs. pic.twitter.com/XIpvt1UsCp
— Wall Street Mav (@WallStreetMav) April 8, 2026
Some did read the law and spotted the underlying agenda early:
But like it or not, it is about amnesty. The bill can be read here. A look through its 261 pages shows that the tough border security it supposedly promotes -- is all things President Trump has already accomplished as he has already secured the border. More fence, e-Verify, fines for amnestied illegals, and the like.
We already have those things, so what are Republicans gaining here? There's nothing in the bill about illegals voting (which ought to be required vetting and instantly deportable as every illegal ballot cast is a disenfranchisement of an American citizen) or taxing remittances, which has created a lot of incentive for tyrants to ship their troublemakers, good and bad, here.
What, again, do Republicans gain from this?
We know the Democrats are gaining.
The bill offers quite a goody bag to the things Democrats have been after which is not just relief from deportation for those who have been in the U.S. for a few years already and have not committed more than two misdemeanors (in one section it says not more than three) or one felony against Americans, with pot offenses and 'nonviolent protest' exempted, meaning, the tire burners and foreign flag wavers, and loud, raging activists who have disrupted Congress (compare and contrast to Jan. 6) or chased Sen. Kyrsten Sinema into the bathroom screaming after her, get to stay with no demerits for their insulting, offensive, disruptions described in their arrests and convictions.
DACA kids, who include some of the loudest offenders on this front, get a full free pass, all 21 million of them, and DACA recipients can qualify up to the age of 18, which is higher than the previous cutoff of age 14.
The three-to-10-year ban on legal admission for those who have already been caught entering illegally and removed is ended. No more deterrent there.
Illegals will get free federal legal to fight the federal law, and better still, the leftist lawyers who aid them will get full student loan forgiveness in their goody packet, incentivizing more legal gaming of the system amid endless appeals.
The list of appeals allowed is long -- appeal after appeal if they don't like the outcome of their cases, and the Attorney General will be free to stay deportations, as many deportations as he likes, for 'family hardship' which we already know means that all you need to do is elect another Democrat to make that happen for all of them.
The 'fine' that illegals will pay to get to stay is ... $1,000 ... which stands in stark contrast to the $20,000 legal immigrants are required to pay for admission farther down in the bill. The bill says illegals will have to be current on their taxes -- and let's see how anyone can enforce that.
And about that $1,000 -- the funding supposedly goes into a money pot to help American workers. One of about two or three dozen already out there, none of which have been useful. Combine it with requirements that the feds deal with NGOs and basically it's the hog wallow again for illegals andagencies like Catholic Charities and other NGOs promoting illegal immigration, the money rolling in and out and the six figure salaries expanding. Rest assured, most of that money will be spent on BMWs, Hawaiian holidays and other luxuries for fraudsters.
Supposedly, illegals will be denied federal benefits, but that's already the law, so once again, another pig in the poke for the Republicans. The problem there is in states which hand out the lavish benefits using fungible federal funding. Nothing there is addressed at all.
Same with asylum abuse, those who fly back to the places they supposedly fled in terror of their lives for vacation losing asylum claims, but that's the already the law, too, this just softens it to a five-year waiting period to take those happy Cuban and Haitian holidays.
CATO guy David Bier, who is libertarian, argues that alarm is overblown:
watch the shock. “This ends mass deportations!” Oh the horror! She acts like having to be in a country with… the exact same people she was before.. would be the end of her world. The only change is that they’d be legal and paying more taxes, and ICE would focus on criminals! https://t.co/yqUta8LQUi
— David J. Bier (@David_J_Bier) April 8, 2026
But it isn''t overblown. It is amnesty. And while I don't hate Salazar or Bier who are often right on many other things, they are wrong on this.
The GOP already has what it wants from President Trump who has secured the border and Democrats are already singing his tune on tough border security, having taken a shellacking in the last election for condoning Joe Biden's open borders. So they haven't given a thing in exchange for their goodie package to Democrats, incentivizing more illegal immigration with mass amnesties and a plethora of crony pork barrel shoveling for Democrat-only agencies such as NGOs. As Milton Friedman has said, you can have open borders, or you can have a welfare state, but you can't have both. This is nothing but another bill for Democrats to 'have both.'